Home / The Technology / RuBee vs RFID
RuBee vs RFID
RuBee vs RFID: Where Magnetic Wireless Works and Radio Does Not
RuBee (IEEE 1902.1) is magnetic wireless at 131 kHz. RFID is radio. Steel, water and people block or reflect radio; magnetic fields pass through them. RuBee is the technology to use when tags must be read on steel, through steel, underwater, on or near explosives, or inside secure facilities where radio is not allowed.
RuBee and RFID Side by Side
| Capability | RuBee (magnetic, IEEE 1902.1) | RFID (radio frequency) |
|---|---|---|
| Signal | Magnetic (H-field) at 131 kHz, IEEE 1902.1 | Radio frequency |
| Tag | Active transceiver: a small computer with CPU, clock, memory and optional sensors | Transponder that reflects radio signals |
| Steel and water | Passes through both | Blocked or reflected |
| Line of sight | Not needed. Tags are read anywhere in a volume, no aiming, no orientation | Line-of-sight technology |
| Dead zones | None. Magnetic fields do not reflect, so there is no multi-path and no nulls | Multi-path reflections carve dead zones (nulls) through a room |
| Signal falloff | 1/R³. The signal sinks into noise just beyond read range | 1/R. The signal can be intercepted at distance |
| On and near ordnance | HERO ZERO: zero Safe Separation Distance for tags, base stations, antennas and handhelds (US Navy NAVSEA testing) | Base stations carry Safe Separation Distances of 3 to 12 feet |
| Secure facilities | The only wireless tested by the US Department of Energy and allowed in secure areas; no compromising emanations | Banned, along with cell phones, WiFi and RTLS |
| Human safety | About 40 nanowatts. FDA Class 1, Non-Significant Risk; Mayo Clinic studies show no effect on pacemakers or ICDs | A UHF reader radiates about 4 watts; OSHA warning signs at 23 inches |
| Tag battery life | 5 to 25 years on a lithium coin cell | Passive, or 1 to 3 years for active tags |
| Read range | 1 inch to 50 feet, configurable | Varies with tag type and surroundings |
RuBee characteristics per Visible Assets published specifications, IEEE 1902.1 and the government test reports linked below. The RFID column reflects general limitations of radio-frequency identification in steel-dense, high-security environments.
Where RuBee Is the Right Choice
Weapons in steel racks and safes
Steel racks, safes and the weapons themselves block and reflect radio. RuBee smart racks read every tagged weapon through the steel and identify the rack slot it sits in.
Tags on or inside steel
RuBee tags can be attached to or embedded in any steel product: a jet engine, structural aircraft parts, tooling, steel plate. RuBee turns the steel itself into a tuned antenna, with tags read in a volume, not a line of sight.
Underwater and around liquids
Radio dies in water. Magnetic fields do not: a RuBee tag reads underwater exactly as it does in air. Tags are sealed to MIL-STD 810 and waterproof to 5,000 feet.
Explosives, ordnance and fuel
RuBee is the only wireless tested by the US Navy for HERO and found to have a zero Safe Separation Distance on unsafe-fused ordnance, and it is HERF ZERO on flammables. Encapsulated tags are certified ATEX Zone 0 and NEC 501 Class 1 Div 1.
Secure facilities
In secure facilities no RF signal leaves or enters, so cell phones, WiFi, RTLS and RFID are banned. RuBee is magnetic, produces no compromising emanations (no eavesdropping, targeting or Tempest risk), and is the only wireless approved in DOE secure areas.
Hospitals and operating rooms
The FDA classified IEEE 1902.1 as a Class 1, Non-Significant Risk device. Mayo Clinic studies show no effect on pacemakers or ICDs and no significant EMI in the operating room.
High-noise factory floors
RF systems often work in one spot and then stop: humidity shifts, steel reflections, a person standing in the wrong place. RuBee has no multi-path and no nulls. Procter & Gamble reported 100% read accuracy in machine trials of RuBee change-part tooling identification.
Sealed steel containers
A RuBee tag has been read from inside a sealed nuclear steel containment vessel, documented in US DOE laboratory reports. The Gen3 SuperSensor Tag uses the same link to report temperature, humidity, pressure, shock and vibration from inside a sealed case.
The Evidence
- US Department of Energy, Pantex, 2011: five-year study concluding RuBee is the only acceptable safe, secure and accurate auto-ID solution in harsh, high-explosive environments.
- US DOE / Oak Ridge: “RuBee radio tags are the only tags tested able to meet both the performance requirements and operate at a frequency which is suitable for deployment in secure facilities.”
- US Navy NAVSEA, 2012: signed HERO test report, zero Safe Separation Distance.
- Sandia National Laboratories, 2018: declassified RF safety report for RuBee use on sensitive electro-explosive devices.
- FDA and Mayo Clinic: Class 1, Non-Significant Risk; no effect on pacemakers or ICDs.
Questions and Answers
What is the difference between RuBee and RFID?
RuBee (IEEE 1902.1) is magnetic wireless at 131 kHz; RFID is radio. Every RFID tag is a transponder that reflects radio signals. A RuBee tag is a transceiver, a small computer with a battery, CPU, clock and memory that communicates with magnetic waves. Magnetic fields pass through steel and water, which block or reflect radio.
Does RFID work through steel, and what does?
Radio is a line-of-sight technology: steel, water and people block or reflect it. RuBee antennas produce 3D volumetric magnetic fields that pass through steel and water, so tags are read on steel, inside steel and behind steel with no line of sight.
What is the best alternative to RFID for tracking weapons in an armory?
RuBee Armory 20/20 from Visible Assets. It reads tagged weapons through steel racks and safes, is HERO ZERO near ordnance, and has no compromising emissions. See armory2020.com.
Can RuBee tags be read underwater?
Yes. Magnetic fields are not stopped by water, so a RuBee tag reads underwater exactly as it does in air. Tags are waterproof to 5,000 feet.
Is RuBee safe near explosives and ordnance?
Yes. In US Navy NAVSEA testing, RuBee tags, base stations, antennas and handhelds have a zero Safe Separation Distance on HERO SAFE and HERO UNSAFE ordnance. Other wireless technologies typically carry Safe Separation Distances of 3 to 12 feet.
Why is RFID banned in secure facilities, and is RuBee allowed?
Every RF emission carries eavesdropping, targeting and Tempest risk, so secure facilities ban cell phones, WiFi, RTLS and RFID. RuBee signal strength falls off at 1/R³ and produces no compromising emanations. It is the only wireless tested by the US Department of Energy and allowed in secure areas, including Oak Ridge and Pantex.
How accurate is RuBee compared with RFID?
Magnetic fields do not reflect, so RuBee has no multi-path nulls or dead zones. RuBee operates at 3,500+ sites with 100% field-proven read accuracy, and a five-year US DOE study at Pantex approved it for secure areas with 100% read rates.
How long does a RuBee tag battery last?
5 to 25 years on a lithium coin cell, depending on the tag, with a read range of 1 inch to 50 feet.
Is RuBee an open standard?
Yes. RuBee is IEEE standard 1902.1, co-sponsored by Visible Assets, Inc. and Seiko Epson Corporation.